DeployU
Interviews / AI & MLOps / What is the difference between `torch.Tensor` and `torch.autograd.Variable`?

What is the difference between `torch.Tensor` and `torch.autograd.Variable`?

conceptual Core Concepts Interactive Quiz Code Examples

The Scenario

You are a senior ML engineer at a research lab. The lab has a large codebase of PyTorch 0.3 code that was written several years ago. The code is used to train a variety of different models, from simple CNNs to more complex RNNs.

The lab has decided to migrate its entire codebase to PyTorch 1.0 to take advantage of the new features and improvements. However, the team is struggling to understand the changes to the autograd API, specifically the deprecation of the Variable class.

Your manager has asked you to create a presentation that explains the difference between the old Variable API and the new Tensor API and provides guidance on how to migrate the existing code.

The Challenge

Explain the difference between the torch.autograd.Variable class and the torch.Tensor class in the context of the PyTorch 0.4.0 release. Why was Variable deprecated, and what are the benefits of the new API? Provide a clear migration path for the existing PyTorch 0.3 code.

Wrong Approach

A junior engineer might not be aware of the history of PyTorch and the evolution of its API. They might try to run the old code in a new version of PyTorch and be confused by the errors.

Right Approach

A senior engineer would be able to provide a detailed explanation of the changes to the `autograd` API in PyTorch 0.4.0. They would also be able to provide a clear migration path for the existing code and would have a deep understanding of the benefits of the new API.

Step 1: Understand the Historical Context

In PyTorch 0.3 and earlier, the torch.autograd.Variable class was a thin wrapper around a torch.Tensor that was used for automatic differentiation.

PyTorch 0.3PyTorch 1.0
Variable and Tensor are two separate classes.Variable and Tensor are merged into one class.
requires_grad is an argument to Variable.requires_grad is an attribute of Tensor.
volatile is used to disable autograd.torch.no_grad() is used to disable autograd.
.data is used to access the underlying tensor..data is still available, but not recommended.

Step 2: The Migration Path

Here is a migration path for the existing PyTorch 0.3 code:

1. Remove Variable wrappers:

The first step is to remove all the Variable wrappers from the code.

PyTorch 0.3:

from torch.autograd import Variable
x = Variable(torch.ones(2, 2), requires_grad=True)

PyTorch 1.0:

import torch
x = torch.ones(2, 2, requires_grad=True)

2. Replace .data with .detach():

The .data attribute should be replaced with the .detach() method. The .detach() method returns a new tensor that shares the same storage as the original tensor, but is detached from the computation graph.

PyTorch 0.3:

x_data = x.data

PyTorch 1.0:

x_data = x.detach()

3. Replace volatile with torch.no_grad():

The volatile argument should be replaced with the torch.no_grad() context manager.

PyTorch 0.3:

x = Variable(torch.ones(2, 2), volatile=True)
y = model(x)

PyTorch 1.0:

with torch.no_grad():
    y = model(x)

Step 3: The Benefits of the New API

The new autograd API is simpler, more consistent, and easier to use than the old API. It also has several performance benefits, such as reduced memory usage and faster execution.

By migrating to the new API, you can take advantage of all the new features and improvements in PyTorch 1.0 and beyond.

Practice Question

You are migrating some old PyTorch code and you see the line `x = Variable(torch.ones(2, 2), volatile=True)`. What should you do?